Gaps at the top levels of your organisation can have far-reaching impacts on decision-making, performance and people management. Finance is no exception.

Perhaps rapid growth, a system implementation or a funding round is adding complication to your company’s financial setup. Maybe a Finance Director is retiring and leaving a hole in the management team that no one is yet equipped to fill.

Whatever the scenario, if your business finds itself without an FD, Financial Controller or CFO, HR might be weighing up whether to fill the position with a temporary appointment or hold out for a permanent placement. The right option for your business depends on the scale of your operation and the strategic importance of the role within your wider organisation.

Define what the appointment needs to achieve

Before making any hiring decisions, you must first identify what you are aiming to achieve with the appointment.

Finance leaders can have a range of business-critical responsibilities, from strategic planning and analysis to reporting, compliance and risk management. Being clear about the role’s requirements will help you narrow down your options.

These requirements often fall into one of the following categories:

  • An ongoing leadership requirement. You need someone to own your finance function and lead on strategy and reporting.
  • A defined piece of work with an identifiable endpoint. You need someone to support a specific project, such as a system implementation or company restructure.
  • A temporary gap in an established role. You need someone to step in for an existing finance leader who is unavailable due to long-term absence or resignation.
  • A requirement that still needs investigation. You need someone to troubleshoot problems in your financial strategy and identify the type of leadership you need.

In some cases, your needs might span more than one of these categories. For example, a Financial Controller might go on sick leave whilst your company is undergoing a statutory audit or you might want a Finance Director to optimise the running of your finance department without knowing exactly where things are currently going wrong. Understanding the full scope of the requirement before you approach your hiring team or a specialist recruitment firm with a brief will help you refine your search.

When to make a permanent appointment

There are several requirements that could indicate the need for a permanent Finance Director or CFO.

  • Developing the finance team. Having a mentor at the helm of your finance team can help cultivate internal talent to better prepare your organisation for future leadership changes.
  • Taking ownership of financial strategy and performance. Appointing someone who is accountable for setting and reaching financial targets can be great for improving year-on-year performance.
  • Building relationships with operational leaders and the board. Establishing trust and understanding between finance and other business divisions takes time, making it a requirement better suited to permanent positions.
  • Supporting the next stage of business growth. Planning for new markets, acquisitions, certifications or investment rounds requires long-term thinking. Putting someone in charge who will be there from development to delivery and bring bigger-picture thinking to the table can support stability during organisational change.

The value of permanent roles compounds with time, fulfilling business needs beyond a single defined project or deliverable.

When to bring in an interim finance leader

If your need for financial leadership is more urgent or short-term, an interim or temporary appointment might make more sense than a permanent hire. These appointments can be more cost-effective when the required responsibilities are defined by time, project or a temporary gap.

  • Covering a temporary gap in the team. An experienced interim leader can step in to cover core reporting and management functions when the usual owner is temporarily unavailable.
  • Delivering a one-off project. A specialist can support the delivery of a defined project, providing focused leadership and oversight that ends at the conclusion of a set period.
  • Diagnosing or stabilising the finance function. An experienced temporary finance leader can be brought in when a business is not meeting its financial targets. They can identify the underlying problem and implement urgent fixes that restore control and ensure service continuity.
  • Bridging the gap until a permanent appointment is made. An interim FD or CFO can often start straight away, which is ideal for teams that need someone to maintain essential finance functions until a permanent candidate is found and onboarded.

With any interim hire, it is important to define the deliverables and who will own any ongoing responsibilities related to the work once the assignment ends.

Five questions to ask before you hire

By this point, you probably have a fairly good idea of the type of appointment you need. But before you make a final decision, there are several practicalities to consider so you can avoid wasting time and money going down the wrong route.

Ask yourself: When must the work begin, and what can candidate availability realistically support?

Permanent candidates often have notice periods to serve, and interim hires might also need some time to get up to speed. Thinking ahead and discussing your immediate and long-term needs with a recruitment specialist can help you decide between permanent and interim and land on a realistic hiring timeline.

Ask yourself: Is the workload achievable with the team and resources available?

No single hire is a silver bullet for all your finance challenges, so it is important to align both internally and externally on realistic expectations for the position. Your hiring brief should paint an honest picture of the demands of the role and the support that will be available for the successful candidate.

Ask yourself: What must the person have delivered previously?

Settle on what is ‘essential’ and what is ‘desirable’ experience for the role and make the level of authority (and associated compensation) clear. For example, will they need to sign off budgets or sit on a senior leadership board? This is especially important for interim hires, as you will need to rely on them to slot in immediately and deliver quick results.

Ask yourself: What will it cost the business if this need is not resolved, and how much will it cost to resolve it properly?

Consider the expected duration and scope of the tasks and responsibilities you are looking for someone to take on, whether that’s the delivery of a project or the development of the wider finance function. Then, weigh the estimated cost of leaving these responsibilities unmanaged, such as the consequences of a missed funding window or a strained relationship with lenders. Compare these costs with the expense of an interim or permanent hire to gauge the most cost-efficient solution.

Ask yourself: When this appointment changes hands, what work needs to carry on and who will make sure it does?

For an interim appointment, ensuring continuity means planning the handover to a permanent hire or the rest of the team from the start. For a permanent hire, it means defining existing gaps and working out how to build the right capabilities and knowledge over time. In either case, you will need to decide who holds relationships with key stakeholders and creditors so they remain strong when teams change internally.

Build a clear hiring brief

Filling an empty FD or CFO seat is vital for any growing operation. The longer the gap remains, the more cracks will appear in your financial reporting, compliance, strategy and leadership. However, rushing the recruitment process for such a business-critical role can lead to false starts and appointments that have to be revisited before the payoff is realised.

Whether you have outgrown your existing finance function and need to plug a structural hole or you want expert support for a specific project, you should be able to answer four questions before you start recruiting:

  • What needs to be achieved, and why?
  • How soon is support required?
  • Which responsibilities will continue past three or six months?
  • What experience and authority will delivery depend on?

Taking the time to define your answers to these questions will help you create a stronger hiring brief that results in more successful recruitment.

At Howett Thorpe, we balance speed with rigour to help you hire right the first time. Our qualified and senior finance division understands the competitive nature of the sector and specialises in recruiting top-tier professionals into full-time, part-time, permanent or temporary positions.

If you need to fill a leadership role in your finance team fast, speak to our experts about where your search should start.

Contact the Howett Thorpe team